Why Driving Myths Persist

Driving myths spread the same way most misinformation does: someone heard it in driver's ed decades ago, a parent repeated it, and it calcified into received wisdom. The problem is that vehicle technology, road design, and safety research have all advanced significantly — and some of the old rules are not just outdated, they're actively counterproductive.

This article walks through the most common misconceptions using current safety research and manufacturer guidance. None of this is a substitute for a formal defensive driving course, but it's a useful starting point for families who want to build habits on solid ground. For a broader look at evidence-based road behavior, see our guide on what defensive driving actually means.

Myth

You should keep your hands at 10 and 2 on the steering wheel.

Fact

Modern safety guidelines recommend the 9-and-3 position, which keeps hands clear of the airbag deployment zone.

The 10-and-2 rule made sense before airbags were standard equipment. Today, if an airbag deploys with hands in the upper position, it can drive arms and hands into the driver's face at high speed. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and most driver training organizations now recommend 9-and-3 — or even 8-and-4 for some drivers — because it keeps arms out of the airbag's path while maintaining good steering control.

Myth

SUVs and trucks are safer than cars because they're bigger.

Fact

Larger vehicles have a significantly higher rollover risk, and size alone does not protect occupants in all crash types.

Height and mass provide some advantage in certain collisions, but they come with trade-offs. A higher center of gravity makes SUVs and trucks more prone to rollovers, which are disproportionately fatal. Modern crossovers with electronic stability control have improved this, but the myth that 'bigger is always safer' ignores rollover risk, longer braking distances, and reduced maneuverability. Vehicle safety ratings from organizations like the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) are a more reliable guide than size alone.

Myth

Hands-free phone calls are safe because your eyes stay on the road.

Fact

Research consistently shows that the cognitive distraction of a phone conversation — not just visual distraction — impairs driving performance.

The brain doesn't multitask; it switches between tasks rapidly, and that switching creates gaps in attention. Studies have found that drivers on hands-free calls miss visual cues, react more slowly, and have crash rates comparable to handheld users. The conversation itself — not the physical act of holding a phone — is the primary impairment. For a full breakdown of what the evidence shows, see our hands-free safety explainer.

Myth

Driving below the speed limit is always the safest choice.

Fact

In certain traffic conditions, driving significantly slower than the flow of traffic can increase collision risk.

Speed differentials between vehicles are a known crash factor. On a highway where traffic is moving at 65 mph, a driver doing 45 mph creates a situation where other vehicles must react quickly to a slow-moving obstacle — similar to the risk posed by a stopped car. This doesn't mean speeding is safe; it means matching the general flow of traffic (within legal limits) and using judgment about conditions. In adverse weather or congested areas, slower speeds are absolutely appropriate.

Myth

Four-wheel drive (4WD) means you can drive normally on ice and snow.

Fact

4WD improves traction when accelerating but does nothing to shorten stopping distances on slippery surfaces.

Four-wheel drive distributes engine power to all four wheels, which helps a vehicle get moving in snow or mud. But braking is governed by tire grip and physics — not drivetrain configuration. An SUV with 4WD stops on ice at the same distance as a front-wheel-drive sedan with similar tires. Overconfidence in 4WD capability is a documented contributor to winter weather crashes. Tire quality and appropriate speed matter far more than drivetrain type in icy conditions.

Myth

Tailgating pushes slow drivers out of the way and gets you there faster.

Fact

Following too closely dramatically increases rear-end collision risk and rarely saves meaningful time.

Reaction time — the gap between perceiving a hazard and applying the brakes — averages about 1.5 seconds for an alert driver. At 60 mph, a vehicle travels roughly 132 feet in that time before braking even begins. Cutting following distance reduces your margin to near zero. Beyond the safety issue, the time saved by tailgating is typically negligible over a normal drive. Our deep dive on why tailgating is more dangerous than most drivers realize covers the numbers in detail.

Rethinking What 'Safe' Looks Like Behind the Wheel

Several myths persist because they feel intuitively correct. Slower always seems safer. Bigger always seems more protective. Hands on the wheel always seems attentive. But intuition and physics don't always agree.

~36%

Of U.S. crash fatalities involving rollover

NHTSA data has consistently shown rollovers account for a disproportionate share of fatal crashes, particularly among SUVs and light trucks.

4x

Increased crash risk from cognitive distraction

Research published by the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety found that highly cognitively demanding tasks — including phone conversations — can quadruple crash risk.

132 ft

Distance traveled before braking at 60 mph

At average reaction time, a vehicle moving at 60 mph covers roughly 132 feet before the driver's foot reaches the brake pedal.

Take following distance. Many drivers underestimate how much space they actually need to stop safely — a problem compounded by speed. Our explainer on stopping distances and why speed matters breaks down the physics in plain terms. Similarly, if you believe hands-free calls are a safe workaround, the evidence suggests otherwise — see hands-free vs. handheld: does the difference matter.

Winter Driving Overconfidence Is a Real Risk

Drivers of 4WD and AWD vehicles are statistically more likely to venture out in severe winter weather — and sometimes to drive faster than conditions warrant. Four-wheel drive cannot overcome the laws of physics on ice. Regardless of drivetrain, slow down, increase following distance, and check road conditions before heading out in snow or freezing rain.

The takeaway isn't that driving is impossibly dangerous — it's that small habit corrections, grounded in current research, add up to meaningfully lower risk for your family. And while you're auditing your road assumptions, it's worth checking whether any cost-related myths are affecting your decisions too: car ownership cost myths that catch families off guard covers common financial blind spots alongside the safety ones.

Share

Cars & Driving Editorial Team · Contributor

Cars & Driving Editorial Team is the collective byline for our editorial team and contributor network. Articles published under this byline or an editorial pen name are researched, written, and reviewed according to our editorial standards for clarity, consistency, and independence before publication.

The content provided on our blog site traverses numerous categories, offering readers valuable and practical information. Readers can use the editorial team’s research and data to gain more insights into their topics of interest. However, they are requested not to treat the articles as conclusive. The website team cannot be held responsible for differences in data or inaccuracies found across other platforms. Please also note that the site might also miss out on various schemes and offers available that the readers may find more beneficial than the ones we cover.